DEM Resulted from Sentinel-1 Insar are very similar to SRTM?

[awardhana]

Guys,

I’m newbie on Sentinel-1 and Lately I was struggle to produce a DEM from Sentinel 1 using Interferometric process in SNAP…
I have passed all step from the tutorial and power point training step by step documentation created by Michael Foumelis “Sentinel 1 TOPS Interferometry”, and I was succeed produced a DEM using SNAP.

but when I’m compared the data from Sentinel-1 Insar result with SRTM 3 Arc, the result was exactly the same, there is no difference between Sentinel-1 Insar and SRTM
See my comparison preview in pic above bottom part:

My question are ?

1. Do the DEM file in the SNAP “Elevation” band that I produced is really data from Interferometric or just another copy of SRTM?
2. Which one should I export Elevation_VV Band or Elevation Band to produce a DEM??
   My Elevation_VV preview is something like in the preview above second from above:
3. Is my Elevation_VV correct? what I’m missing?
4. What is the Maximum DEM Resolution can produced by Sentinel-1 with Sensor Mode IW.

Please Help

Thanks a lot guys

Arya Wardhana
Indonesia

[ABraun]

2. Which one should I export Elevation_VV Band or Elevation Band to produce a DEM??

you need absolute elevations for the generation of InSAR DEMs.

• Elevation_VV is the one based on Sentinel-1
• Elevation is your SRTM down-sampled to the spatial resolution of Sentinel-1

The quality of your dem is strongly affected by coherence and atmospheric disturbances.

The best resolution from Sentinel-1 IW mode is around 13 meters, at least to my experience.

[awardhana]

Thanks for your reply

Can you describe a bit about absolute elevations and how to do it?
Is there any tutorial URL link for me to follow?

Thanks

[ABraun]

http://step.esa.int/main/doc/tutorials/

[mengdahl]

The S-1 DEM will contain (possibly large) errors due to atmospheric artifacts.

[awardhana]

Thanks for the reply

How can I avoid the atmosperic artifact?
Is there any parameter on the SLC files that is indicated that the atmosperic distrubence is high or low?

If you analyse my elevation_vv result above, what should I do, should I change my SLC files?

Thanks before

Regards
Arya

[asifokaravi]

how to extract the DEM of September 2017 using Sentinel-1 data.
I will be thank full to you.

[ABraun]

please see this example:

The Order of DEM Creating Steps

I am trying to create a DEM over my AOI. After reading plenty of topics, I have obtained a pair of S1A and S1B data. The baseline is 143.48 which is the longest I could find. As I read, it should be between 150 and 300 and around 70% of the values in the coherence histogram should be above 0.4. This is the histogram of my recent and best attempt. [image] After applying the steps below; 1) S1 TOPS Coregistration 2) Creating Interferogram 3) Debursting 4) Goldenstein Phase Filtering 5) Mu…

[Hornbeam]

Thanks for useful tips

I have opposite problem to author of topic: my InSAR DEM is higher more than 20 meters than SRTM. Why does it happen?

[ABraun]

Can you explain this a bit more? Maybe with screenshots

[Hornbeam]

Here I have two DEMs: InSAR elevation obtained after interferometry anf SRTM. I used SRTM 3ArcSec to produce InSAR dem. So, it have to have close value of elevation value. But you can see on this screenshot that the value is different on more than 20m. The value is taken from the pixel corresponding a lake. Nothing have change after almost 20 years - the same lake on the same territory. And such difference appears on all my InSAR DEMs.
Why it could happen: values of two DEMs built from the same source are different on 20m.

Thank you for feedback.

[ABraun]

InSAR generates relative topographies which are then leveled to a surface using a DEM. Accordingly, there can be differences between the InSAR DEM and the outcome due to low coherence, atmospheric disturbance or unwrapping errors. Please have a look here, especially chapters 3.4 “From phase to elevation” and 3.5 “Error sources”: http://www.esa.int/esapub/tm/tm19/TM-19_ptB.pdf

[Hornbeam]

Thank you for answer

I read this handbook. The situation is troublesome because such difference in 22-25 meters is constant for every SLC pare. Moreover, for every territory investigated + on every computer + for every operator (I am working in group). Can you explain, on which step relative topographies leveled to a surface using DEM (if I understand your firs sentence right)? I thing it leveled at the step “Terrain Correction”, didn’t it?
Here I show the coherence

Is it low?

[Hornbeam]

Dear readers, I’m still working with this issue. Does anybody have an idea, how to cope with difference in 20m between DEM generated from Sentinel-1 SLC and true elevation.
I have posted screenshots DEM Resulted from Sentinel-1 Insar are very similar to SRTM?

Thank you, and sorry for this offtop

[GameM]

Hi,
I had same issue, with 40m of elevation difference between true elevation and S1 SLC. My professor guessed, that 40m is actually the height above the geoid, in my AOI. So i added a new line to snap properties “snap.useDEMGravitationalModel = false” and made a new elevation model and it worked.

[daffadinan]

excuse me, can u tell me how is the step?

[ABraun]

please specify your question.